Evolution of specific practices, and as we discuss in analysis. In what context can these derived states of humans be considered exaptations. The authors present a balanced critique of the adaptation exaptation debate and specify some of the hard evidentiary criteria that are needed to advance our understanding of human evolution. From primate social learning to human culture, proceedings of the national academy of science, 101, pp. It follows from the definition of culture as information capable of affecting individuals behavior that they acquire from other members of their species through teaching, imitation and other forms of social transmission. Explaining the origins of cumulative culture, and how it is maintained over long timescales, constitutes a challenge for theories of cultural evolution. Theories of cultural evolution address cultural trends in their own right, rather than as outputs of. The national academy of sciences published a set of papers on cultural evolution recently. Recently, however, a new position has emerged in this debate, as an influential new theory based. We present several examples of exaptation, indicating where a failure to concep tualize such an. This illusory perception of a self also conditions scientific activity, giving birth to a new form of knowledge that attributes a new value judgment to. Jun 11, 20 the term exaptation was introduced to encourage biologists to consider alternatives to adaptation to explain the origins of traits. Nov 26, 2019 explaining the origins of cumulative culture, and how it is maintained over long timescales, constitutes a challenge for theories of cultural evolution. So far, we have proposed how culturevia what we have called cultural exaptationmay be seen as the driving force of human cognitive evolution fig.
Investigators must build more special design criteria into their theorizing and research. Both technology and science are prime examples of cumulative. Jul 22, 2018 moreover, cultural exaptation is fully compatible with losses of cultural innovations and is not inevitably cumulative. On the basis of recent advancements in both neuroscience and archaeology, we propose a plausible biocultural mechanism at the basis of cultural evolution. A key threshold for defining a cultural species is cumulative cultural evolution. In recent years, the phenomenon of cumulative cultural evolution cce has become the focus of major research interest in biology, psychology and anthropology. A cultural species is one that has evolved to socially transmit complex behaviorshaping information between generations. This phenomenon has been called exaptation, an alternative to adaptation. Together, cultural exaptation and cultural neural reuse may give raise to a plausible general mechanism for cognitive evolution in which culture is the driving force, thus offering a top. Exaptation, adaptation, and evolutionary psychology people. The origins of music in auditory scene analysis and the. The targets of explanation for evolutionary psychology and geneculture coevolutionary accounts differ from those of theories of cultural evolution.
In particular, as i try to make clearer in what follows, there is a major disconnect in how. The theory of cultural evolution offers the field of religious evolution a powerful set of concepts for explaining important traits and facts that are not explained by genetic evolution. Technology refers to goaloriented shared knowledge together with its external means. However, the particular kind of approach that was used by social scientists depended more on the other theories that were prevalent at the time. Simulating the origin of syntax mark bartlett doctor of philosophy university of york department of computer science october 2006. Exaptation, adaptation, and evolutionary psychology page 4 the second preliminary point that needs to be addressed concerns the definition of exaptation.
Here, we discuss why exaptation has proved more successful in technological than biological contexts, and propose a revised definition of exaptation applicable to both genetic and cultural evolution. The idea of social evolution came from the biological model of evolution. I just cant pinpoint what he wants, because i came up with a few ideas. The term exaptation was introduced to encourage biologists to consider alternatives to adaptation to explain the origins of traits. Sometimes evolution puts a trait to a new use, for instance, feathers evolved before flight. The concept of exaptation, introduced to evolutionary biology by. In taoist myth, this division depicts the evolution of human consciousness, endowing man with an analytical, sequential, and logical mind that substitutes myths for reason as the true engine of knowledge.
Sociocultural epistasis and cultural exaptation in. Sociocultural epistasisassociation of cultural ideas with the hierarchical structure of social rolesin. Sep 12, 2018 on the basis of recent advancements in both neuroscience and archaeology, we propose a plausible biocultural mechanism at the basis of cultural evolution. An exaptation is just one example of a characteristic that evolved, but that isnt considered an adaptation. The cultural evolution of technology and science 195 we can therefore distinguish between knowledge itself the product and the means by which that knowledge is acquired and transmitted the process. Cultural evolution is the change of this information over time. The idea behind this mechanism is that cultural innovations have direct effects on the cognitive capabilities of populations of hominins via what we call cultural exaptation.
It is thus knowledge geared to, and organized around, solving. My professor gave the example of giving a thumbs up for the exaptation of the thumb. Marshall sahlins, coeditor with elman service of evolution and culture 1960, divided the evolution of societies into general and specific. Exaptation and grammaticalization elizabeth closs traugott stanford university. The evolution of human cultural capacities and cultural evolution. Exaptation and grammaticalization elizabeth closs traugott. Unlike in the case of adaptation, though, the issues here get fairly complex fairly quickly. Cultural evolution is an evolutionary theory of social change. This article argues that exaptation overcomes the fallacy of human sociobiology, helps us to understand the major patterns of flexibility and contingency in lifes history, revises the roles of structure and function in evolutionary theory, serves as a centerpiece for grasping the origin and meaning of brain size in human evolution, and thereby. We then discuss the challenges of developing a formal model of exaptation, and in particular why we believe a classical probabilistic framework is insu cient. This has been amended to the following online and in the pdf version.
Pdf the cultural evolution of technology and science. Social learning is also an important agent of adaptation, and perhaps of speciation, in animals. Human cultural evolution, including language change. Exaptation and the related term cooption describe a shift in the function of a trait during evolution. This is due to the fact that language change operates through cultural evolution, rather than genetic evolution steels. Barve and wagners work adds to a growing number of examples of exaptation at the molecular level. At the biochemical level, we have theories of neutralism and suggestions that sub. The proposed mechanism, which relies on the notions of cultural exaptation and cultural neural reuse, may account for the asynchronous, discontinuous, and patchy emergence of innovations around the globe. Here, i attempt to explain why modern humans existed long before socio cultural evolution really began. Sep 04, 20 barve and wagners work adds to a growing number of examples of exaptation at the molecular level. Exaptations are common in both anatomy and behaviour. Evolutionary biologists stephen gould and elizabeth vrba proposed vocabulary to let biologists talk about features that are and are not adaptations. Compared to processes of biological evolution, the rate of language change is fast. Most of the relevant work occurs within a pair of closely related approaches.
A computational study reveals surprising flexibility hidden within metabolic networks, providing new evidence for an evolutionary concept called exaptation. The targets of explanation for evolutionary psychology and gene culture coevolutionary accounts differ from those of theories of cultural evolution. Until recently, human artifacts were not obviously more complex than those made by organisms that lack cultural learning and have limited cognitive capacities. Sep 16, 20 sometimes evolution puts a trait to a new use, for instance, feathers evolved before flight. Pdf developments in cognitive neurosciences and scientific anthropology are.
Theoretical frameworks in cultural evolution have also recognized the importance of exaptation in the domains of technology boyd et al. Cultural stability and diversity, trends in cognitive science, 8, pp. Gabora, scott, and kauffman 20 developed a mathematical framework for exaptation with examples from both biological evolution and the evolution of cultural novelty through innovation. Cultural adaptation is a relatively new concept used to define the specific capacity of human beings and human societies to overcome changes of their natural and social environment by modifications to their culture. In this article it is argued that exaptation is not a rare, oneoff process, as is often assumed, but may come in successive waves, both in biological evolution, where the term originated, and in cultural evolution, including linguistics. Cultural exaptation of cultural ideas, occurred because their association with role expectations changed due to a renegotiation of roleholder recruitment. The problem1 in recent years the term exaptation has come to be used fairly widely, most. But the theory of cultural evolution itself faces important challenges, and is often misunderstood, and focusing on religion makes some abstract and difficult. Nevertheless, socio cultural evolution did not end biological evolution.
We document the existence of cultural exaptation, where a. The state of a trait is written as a linear superposition of a set of basis states, or possible forms the trait could evolve into, in a complex hilbert space. For example, a trait can evolve because it served one particular function, but subsequently it may come to serve another. Exaptation and grammaticalization elizabeth closs traugott stanford university published in minoji akimoto, ed. In association with the evolution of bipedal locomotion, many derived states of hind limb anatomy evolved as adaptations for efficient walking and running. White energy and the evolution of culture 339 human species the struggle for survival assumes the cultural form. Jun, 2018 in recent years, the phenomenon of cumulative cultural evolution cce has become the focus of major research interest in biology, psychology and anthropology. Exaptation is a process of linguistic change where obsolescent morphology is refunctionalized. The gradual cumulative cultural evolution of locally adaptive technologies has played a crucial role in our species rapid expansion across the globe. Section 2 very briefly mentions some of the work on exaptation in evolution. The self as a cultural exaptation the idea of self seems to be conditioned by socio cultural. Pdf the cultural evolution of technology facts and. Dentinoenamel junction 187 words exact match in snippet view article find links to article which has occurred as an exaptation of the epithelial folding that is undergone during ontogeny. We develop a quantum framework for exaptation with examples from both biological and cultural evolution.
Some researchers argue that cce is unique to humans and underlies our extraordinary evolutionary success as. Harris, and michael wanzenried a fundamental problem for anthropological archaeology lies in defining and explaining the evolutionary origins of social inequality. Some researchers argue that cce is unique to humans and underlies our extraordinary evolutionary success as a species. Cultural evolution stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Thornton, for example, has studied the evolution of hormones and their receptors, which fit together like lock and key. Exaptationa missing term in the science of form search faculty. The phenomenon of preadaptation, or exaptation wherein a trait that originally evolved to solve one problem is coopted to solve a new problem presents a formidable challenge to efforts to describe biological phenomena using a classical kolmogorovian mathematical framework. Exaptation definition is a trait, feature, or structure of an organism or taxonomic group that takes on a function when none previously existed or that differs from its original function which had been derived by evolution.
The question is not so much whether cultural evolution is important, but how theories of cultural evolution should be fashioned, and how they should be related to more traditional understandings of organic evolution. On the other hand, it has also been proposed that music is not an evolution ary adaptation, but rather a cultural creation that can stimulate pleasure centres in the brain e. Exaptation definition of exaptation by merriamwebster. This resembles exaptation in genetic evolution 43, and we label this cultural exaptation. Exaptation, adaptation, and evolutionary psychology. Last year marked a decade since the death of stephen jay. Under the right circumstances, he found, one half of a partnership can be coopted to give rise to a new hormonereceptor system. The idea of self as an exaptation arises from the cultural development of our species closely influenced by the ripening of our cognitive structures and the evolution of human natural language. Recently, however, a new position has emerged in this debate, as an influential new theory.
Darwin fail on arrival heres why theories on the evolution of human culture are doomed from the getgo. The cultural evolution of material wealthbased inequality at bridge river, british columbia anna marie prentiss, thomas a. The word evolution comes from the latin evolvere, literally meaning an unrolling. Pdf darwinism and the cultural evolution of sports researchgate. This chapter explores how the principles and methods of cultural evolution can inform our understanding of technology and science. The first part of this essay is an attempt to understand what sort of theory of human cultural evolution darwin proposed in the descent of man, which is difficult for two reasons. However, cultural evolution creates adaptive tools much more rapidly than genetic. Others claim to have found cce in nonhuman species. The human struggle for existence expresses itself in a neverending attempt to make of cul ture a more effective instrument with which to provide security of life and sur vival of the species. The process of evolutionchanges over time in organic.
801 952 994 948 987 760 571 1634 1399 688 432 1474 400 1291 62 1589 545 917 126 691 649 852 1597 1003 910 1262 1275 339 1186 1608 1358 1244 1227 826 1457 228 278 1234 842 7 280 737 143 689 379 1132 570